I live near Horsetooth at an altitude of 5800 ft..... I CANNOT make hard boiled eggs that peel easily without damaging the whites. Generally I start w...
Knowledgebase
Cooking PERFECT hard boiled eggs #926197
Asked March 17, 2026, 6:49 PM EDT
I live near Horsetooth at an altitude of 5800 ft..... I CANNOT make hard boiled eggs that peel easily without damaging the whites. Generally I start with cold water in a pan big enough for eggs to move; bring to a low boil then reduce to a simmer (~5 setting) and simmer for 17 min (in Iowa I cooked for 15 min with NO problem); ice bath for 15 min. Whether I peel immediately, or refrigerate and peel later, I rarely get an easy peel and the whites are a mess! I usually peel from the fat end first as that's where to air pocket is and I try to gently use my thumb pad to push the shell away, trying to make sure I'm getting under the membrane. If I do, then I have good luck but often the membrane sticks to the white and tears it. Do "Colorado eggs" have thicker/thinner membranes than elsewhere. I've tried adding baking soda or vinegar to the water... no difference. I've tried the "no heat method" - turning heat off after boiling, cover and let sit) but then the yolks don't get done. Help me as Easter is coming!!!!
Larimer CountyColorado
Expert Response
Hello and thank you for reaching out to Ask Extension! To best help you with this inquiry, we recommend you contact your local county directly. Larimer County's email and phone are below.